Effect of mesh size and turbulence on the simulation results





Generally, the agreement between simulation and experimental results improve as the mesh size used in the simulations decreases. It is also frequently found that, as the fluid velocities increase, turbulence is needed in the fluid flow simulations to obtain agreement with experimental observations. The need for fine mesh and the incorporation of turbulence in the fluid flow simulations for the phenomena taking place in the die casting shot sleeve have been noted in this work. Six simulations are provided in this section; 2 each, one for laminar and one with turbulence, for three different numbers of mesh. The total number of mesh used are 2,244, 24,000, and 60,000 cells in the same shot sleeve described in the introduction to this section.
 

Simulation Results

* Plunger velocity = 80cm/s, acceleration time = 0.1 sec, 50% fill, water density and viscosity, No surface tension
* Initial condition : flat free surface (There are no velocities in the fluid)
 

1. Mesh : 150*400, Turbulent
2. Mesh : 150*400, Laminar

3. Mesh : 80*300, Turbulent

4. Mesh : 80*300, Laminar
5. Mesh : 22*102, Turbulent
6. Mesh : 22*102, Laminar


Results and Conclusions:

 As the plunger velocity increases, finer mesh size and/or a greater number of cells are required to obtain wave motions in keeping with those observed experimentally. Specifically, the larger number of cells and the incorporation of turbulence in the simulations are required to produce waves which both reach the top of the shot sleeve at the proper position or time during plunger movement and cascade in the fashion observed in the experimental water physical models. With insufficient number of cells and the lack of turbulence, the simulated waves formed during the plunger movement do not behave in keeping with the experimentally observed ones. A 150x400 mesh system and inclusion of the k-e turbulence model appear to adequately allow simulation of the wave dynamics associated with the shot sleeve portion of the die casting process.